"Better Living, Through Not Getting Killed"
A Journal of Integrated Combatives, Self Defense, Survival and Weapon-craft.

Tuesday, December 16, 2008

A Lesson on Combat Knives, in Two Parts: The MOD XSF-1, and the Mil-Tac CS1


The Mil-Tac Combat Survival 1 (Left) and the Blackhawk XSF-1 (Right)

There is, in the knife community, an undue fascination with “fighting” and “combat” knives. Lots of collectors, enthusiasts, and makers specialize in these types of blades. Some of them are fine people, but most with an interest in, or god save us an opinion on, such knives lack the weight of need or experience to lend their ideas validity. Yet it is often this lot who have their voice raised above those of the truly experienced and it is their cacophony which drives a large part of the "tactical" knife world. Not because they are right, but often because they have, if nothing else, immense buying power.
However, there remain voices and talents in the industry who, on the weight of their background or the strength of their products, have every right and reason to speak up. Not that they always do, some of these talents seem to prefer letting their products do the talking, and keep their voices low. Some are out-spoken, and on the vocal forefront of the industry, but have earned their place there. In either case it is to these talents that people of an experienced need and background go for cutlery. They do so trusting that what they are buying is not hype, is not a “name”, is in fact nothing but a well designed, well executed performance tool.
These opposing forces are not in balance however. The demand for knives to suit the enthusiast market is much higher than for knives to actually be used, particularly in the “tactical” field. There is money to be made from the fancy, the different, the new and shiny. Hype and gadgetry have made more people money than reliability and proven forms...

[Read The Rest: Click Here]


.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

This review leans heavily on the side of wilderness survival in my opinion. The XSF-1 was designed as a thrusting tool. That was the whole concept behind Brent Beshara's creation. To put it up against a slicer like the CS-1 is like pitting a spear against a sabre... Both are very different tools for specialized jobs. Blackhawk has done a fairly decent job in it's representation of the XSF-1... but they decided to add a secondary bevel to the chisel grind... this affects the cutting ability of the knife dramatically. The true Besh Wedge has a zero ground single bevel. I suggest you read Michael Janich's review of the knife. The link is available on Brent's site.

I still enjoyed reading your review and like your writing style. I just wanted to point out what I felt was a misrepresentation of a highly effective tool for its intended purpose.

Rick

Combative Concepts said...

Rick - Thanks for your comments.
This review does focus heavily on Utility. Wilderness survival as such is not the main focus, but provides some excellent framework for evaluating for hard use.
My point was not to evaluate the XSF-1 as a fighting knife. I know no soldiers who carry strictly fighting knives - Not to say there aren't any, but in my experience, they are rare. A knife for a soldier is primarily a utility tool - Those utilities resemble any other back-country hard use.

The XSF-1 was designed to solve a problem that has occured, classically, when fighting daggers were misused by field soldiers who took them for tools and broke their brittle tips. By that very design intention, the XSF-1 is opened up to criticism as a full-fledged Combat Knife, for utility concerns.

Yes, it is an excellent stabber. So is a flat blade screw-driver. It takes more than that to make a knife. Particularly a hard use knife for harsh environments.

I am very familiar with Mr. Janich's review of the XSF-1. I'm glad it works for him.
I am also glad the the custom version is zero-ground, to give it a more usable edge.
However - The MOD version is not, and unless they change that, it remains rather non-functional for the real world needs of soldiers, tactical officers, etc. - The target market for the XSF-1.

Your comments are appreciated, thanks for reading!
So you know, this blog is no longer being updated as we are no longer "Combative Concepts" - We are now BFE Labs.
Please check us out at http://BFELabs.blogspot.com

Thanks!
Morgan

Anonymous said...

Mr. Janich is a Skilled and knowledgeable Person. BUT, Sorry to say Any Review He does on a MOD or Blackhawk knife can't be taken seriously. He's Their Main Spokesperson, PR Man for blades!!!!!!!

Combative Concepts said...

Agreed.
One of the reasons I felt a review of this knife was needed from an independent voice.

Please, in the future, post comments at the new blog: http://bfelabs.blogspot.com/ - where the full articles are found.

About Me

A Journal of Modern Combatives & Survival
Authored by M. Atwood: Former EMT, Professional Knife-Maker, Blacksmith and Medical/Survival Kit Builder. Sometimes Instructor, and part-time Art Teacher.